Gender issues in shakespeares the taming of the shrew and zeffirellis film adaptation
The constant issues of unfair treatment from King George III and his tyranny ultimately led the American colonies to harbor anger and tried to strive for a better life.
Taming ofthe shrew social issues
Not only modern productions of the play, but the text itself suggests that Shakespeare is critical of Petruchio rather than intent on holding him up as a paragon of woman-taming. Katherina reminds Baptista that there is: No shame but mine. Both men and women have their weapons to try and control the other. It is more likely that Zeffirelli uses Shakespeare to make a statement of contemporary life. The word of a man only just met apparently holds more weight than the word of his daughter whom he raised. Why would this be so. Rutter, Carol Chillington. Cartmell, Deborah. This view seems consistent with the position the film would have us take, in which Kat moves from a kind of arrested sexual development imposed from outside into mature heterosexuality that emanates from within. The lines of Shakespeare are sometimes changed around in order to fit the purpose of the movie and to show this equality. Furthermore, through all the physical activity in the film there is almost no 7 room left contemplating in detail the differences between male and female roles. In , the need for political uprising in America was seen by many as nonexistent, and groups actively seeking a revolution were pushed toward the fringes of culture; even some members of socially marginalized communities, including many in queer communities, saw no cause for struggle. The Taming of a Shrew, The frame narrative is concluded in this anonymous play, which may have been a source for Shakespeare. Moments later, on that April day in first grade, my best friend and I experienced the injustices of womanhood; our teachers informed us that we were not allowed to go shirtless during recess. So Katherina is worthy of punishment and a publicly humiliating punishment at that.
She then realises that Lucentio is watching her and reverts back to her silent introvert self and softly tells her father that she will abide by his wishes. As Emma Smith points out,  modern productions of the play virtually never show an unequivocally tamed Katherina.
Taming of the shrew message
Halfway into the twentieth century many male paradigms were changed due to feminists who wanted gender equality. Duggan, Lisa. To protect the anonymity of contributors, we've removed their names and personal information from the essays. Paramount, Hapgood, Robert. Bristol, Michael D. The Taming of the Shrew and the Trouble with Obedience. New York: Routledge, In real life they were also a couple and their turbulent relationship was in the back of many minds while watching this movie Holderness 67; Cartmell See Also. The Taming of the Shrew is about how Petruchio tries to mould his wife Katherina into his ideal wife.
Inthe need for political uprising in America was seen by many as nonexistent, and groups actively seeking a revolution were pushed toward the fringes of culture; even some members of socially marginalized communities, including many in queer communities, saw no cause for struggle.
According to the logic of the film, women are only diverted from the yearnings of manifest femininity when some form of psychological injury rape, maternal abandonment—both affect Kat—or the death of a parent causes girls to construct a defense mechanism of non-normativity.
In the way the statement draws upon the hypocrisies of our ongoing society and social interactions it highly relates to the ordeals in both The Taming of the Shrew and Ten Things I Hate About You.
Taming ofthe shrew gender reversal
It is incorrect to say Zeffirelli is against Shakespeare. Her hair is unbound and wild and her body language conveys aggression. London: Routledge, During this early scene of unruliness, Kate smiles only when she has outwitted a competitor, as when she finally thinks she has escaped Petruchio in the elaborate chase scene Zeffirelli has added to the story; she even cackles out a laugh when she flees to the upper loft of the barn. As we can see both parties are very forward about sex, by making Katherina seem so similar to Petruchio allows the reader to see how masculine her character is and reminds us of how opposite she is to her sister. Friedman, Michael D. In the film, we will only see her smile once more. Her choking anger, expressed by the caesura at 3. Her shrewishness ultimately proves itself not feminist or subversive in any way; it is merely a shield against psychic trauma. DreamWorks SKG,
Yet Kate ultimately outwits and evades her husband, leaving him to his chauvinistic buffoonery, no longer to have a well-tamed woman by his side. The narrative question which is set up at the outset of this play is who will win this particular battle of the sexes?
Bristol, Michael D. Others may argue that she is not shrewish but just a very strong willed person. Nevertheless, one cannot help but wonder if this is truly a tamed Kate.
It seems cruel because, in fact, Sly cannot escape his lowliness.
based on 58 review